18-07-2023, 05:45 PM
As alluded to in the post I linked to, MakeMKV doesn't affect the content of the files. "MakeMKV literally just takes the video and audio streams from the DVD VOB files and puts them in a Matroska MKV wrapper - leaving the actual video and audio data untouched. "
I only have had to deinterlace stuff that was recorded exclusively on video, as you get the whole "judder judder judder" thing if you just do it with Handbrake. It works fine on MakeMKV. That's all I can tell you based on my experience.
I think you're doing something wrong, but I don't know what you're doing. How are you playing your ripped files? Kodi? VLC? Some other software/solution? Something else? Note that also was alluded to in the TV Forum thread: "Never judge any video quality on a laptop, PC monitor, tablet or phone ... Only ever make judgements on a display that is correctly displaying your content at the right refresh rate."
You could just MakeMKV the main video of a DVD and play that in whatever solution you're using and see what happens.
I only have had to deinterlace stuff that was recorded exclusively on video, as you get the whole "judder judder judder" thing if you just do it with Handbrake. It works fine on MakeMKV. That's all I can tell you based on my experience.
I think you're doing something wrong, but I don't know what you're doing. How are you playing your ripped files? Kodi? VLC? Some other software/solution? Something else? Note that also was alluded to in the TV Forum thread: "Never judge any video quality on a laptop, PC monitor, tablet or phone ... Only ever make judgements on a display that is correctly displaying your content at the right refresh rate."
You could just MakeMKV the main video of a DVD and play that in whatever solution you're using and see what happens.