03-05-2023, 03:41 PM
Dan Wootton opened the 8pm hour, after the news, with rolling coverage. Dan was ok in that role, surprisingly.
(03-05-2023, 03:13 PM)Worzel Wrote:(03-05-2023, 02:56 PM)Stooky Bill Wrote: Handled it well by staying put once being told to evacuate? I know he's not primarily a broadcaster but it's very unprofessional and put both them and their crew at risk.No different to the way Tom Bradby handled ITV News at Ten's fire alarm or the various times Channel 4 News had to evacuate because of similar instances at Gray's Inn Road over the years.
Incidently where were they? Is that portacabin where GB News is going to be presenting their coronation coverage from?
Did Tom receive criticism for sitting through a report while the alarm was going off and then evacuate whilst in vision? No.
GB News does get a lot of flack, sometimes rightly, but I can't see how JRM could've handled it any better. When he was told to evacuate he calmly wrapped up the show and handed back to the studio, where I believe Nigel Farage picked up. (There's literally 15 seconds cut out of that clip linked above).
youtu.be
(03-05-2023, 04:17 PM)Stooky Bill Wrote: Presumably they were told to evacuate before the controlled explosion. They don't just decide to do a controlled explosion a few seconds before they do it, neither do they do it without spending some time clearing the area first. At the start of the clip they were already debating whether they needed to or not. It was only when someone came into the hut and explicitly told them that they finally wrapped it up.I think it's also a good example of where good production would (should) come in. Clearly there wasn't a producer empowered enough to shut JRM and his odious guest down; typically speaking the producer is the one responsible for health and safety and it shouldn't ever really be a case that a presenter is calling the shots and acting in such a dangerous way.
It's not the same as Tom Bradbury, TV studios have proper fire systems with staged alerts. He was acting on information from the gallery and ITNs facilities management. JRM was on OB in some sort of shed. Judging by how loud the explosion was it was in the immediate area of Buckingham Palace so lots of police and security presence to tell them what to do
If you're on an OB and police move you on, you move on. No questions. You don't give excuses like 'it's ok I've worked in war zones' or 'the explosion has happened now, do we still need to evacuate?' Can you imagine that happening on any other channel?
If anything it's a good demonstration of his sense of privilege - 'no no no that order to evacuate isn't for me, that's for normal people'
(03-05-2023, 04:17 PM)Stooky Bill Wrote: If anything it's a good demonstration of his sense of privilege - 'no no no that order to evacuate isn't for me, that's for normal people'
(03-05-2023, 04:17 PM)Stooky Bill Wrote: Even if they weren't told before the start of the clip they would have been aware they might need to leave. The incident had been under way a while and they were planning a controlled explosion. They don't just decide to do a controlled explosion a few seconds before they do it, neither do they do it without spending some time clearing the area first. At the start of the clip they were already debating whether they needed to or not. It was only when someone came into the hut and explicitly told them that they finally wrapped it up.
It's not the same as Tom Bradbury, TV studios have proper fire systems with staged alerts. He was acting on information from the gallery and ITNs facilities management. JRM was on OB in some sort of shed. Judging by how loud the explosion was it was in the immediate area of Buckingham Palace so lots of police and security presence to tell them what to do
If you're on an OB and police move you on, you move on. No questions. You don't give excuses like 'it's ok I've worked in war zones' or 'the explosion has happened now, do we still need to evacuate?' Can you imagine that happening on any other channel?
If anything it's a good demonstration of his sense of privilege - 'no no no that order to evacuate isn't for me, that's for normal people'
(03-05-2023, 03:13 PM)Worzel Wrote:(03-05-2023, 02:56 PM)Stooky Bill Wrote: Handled it well by staying put once being told to evacuate? I know he's not primarily a broadcaster but it's very unprofessional and put both them and their crew at risk.No different to the way Tom Bradby handled ITV News at Ten's fire alarm or the various times Channel 4 News had to evacuate because of similar instances at Gray's Inn Road over the years.
Incidently where were they? Is that portacabin where GB News is going to be presenting their coronation coverage from?
Did Tom receive criticism for sitting through a report while the alarm was going off and then evacuate whilst in vision? No.
GB News does get a lot of flack, sometimes rightly, but I can't see how JRM could've handled it any better. When he was told to evacuate he calmly wrapped up the show and handed back to the studio, where I believe Nigel Farage picked up. (There's literally 15 seconds cut out of that clip linked above).
youtu.be