[Former Member 237]

Very sceptical of that "report". Why would the action result in people switching to GB news? most who are going to switch would have already done So. And even to suggest people would switch to Talk TV? I'm afraid there is not much logic in that.



Also with the claims of footage no longer being produced, this makes hardly any sense, the BBC is not closing down overseas. Reports will still be produced. The same argument can be made with the claim about local content. As far as I am aware only one region is going.



In short this report will not change anything.

Sorry to be so crude, but I think your remarks are utter nonsense. That guardian is more or less correct. Of course there is a fair amount of 'personal feeling' in it having come from a group of people who face redundancy, of which I know a handful. You only have to read this thread and the thread that came before it to know it is a bonkers idea that is not in favour of this merger.



Dear @admin - it is possible to run a poll on your new site? It would really interesting to get a Shan-shot from News fans as to this proposed change.

So the harmony lasted about five minutes I think I will go back to staying away.  



I am not sure what knowing people who are being made redundant has to do with anything. I understand it might stir emotions, but that is irrelevant in terms of the discussion. Unless they have explained to you why the Guardian is correct. And if that is the case I have not seen a sufficient explanation. I can only refer you to the end of the Guardian article which has a statement from the BBC. This suggests the "report" has no foundation and I have to say I do agree. There is more than one person that works for the broadcaster here and not all share the views of the Guardian. Such arrogance has already closed down two forums, but alas I will leave you to your echo chamber. Will the last one out please turn out the light.....