[Neil Jones]

Those "VHS" filters don't usually look like VHS either, unless it's a heavily worn tape that's gone down several generations.

I have yet to see a VHS filter that looks anything like, well VHS basically.  Its either too "clean" or its clearly been downsampled from shooting in HD/4k in the first place, although I suspect that may be because all that's shot digitally these days to files.

I'd suggest its one of those production techniques that needs do it properly or don't do it at all.  Get a VHS recorder and feed your shiny digital footage through it.  Yes it'll look like crap afterwards but at least it'll be genuine crap