22-03-2023, 10:42 AM
(22-03-2023, 07:14 AM)ALV Wrote:(22-03-2023, 05:55 AM)Renap Wrote: If it is repositioned it can work like so.Your idea might work for the generic bulletins...
Either way it's just disappointing that yet again they are delaying any replacement. They have had a long time to sort this out.
And yes, I am of the one who thinks that a complete overhaul is needed, including music. It is after all a new era of BBC News, for better or worse.
In before they find another pre-production track (as heard with Reporting Scotland) and call that the "replacement"!
Not so sure about the national bulletins though... the numbers might get wayyy to close to the overscan border? And it immediately contrasts the huge void on the left... Maybe they need to find a way to put the numbers on the left instead.
If I were a betting man, I bet they'll largely keep the titles as they are, remove the final globe frame and bolt on the sting animation at end from 2008 (minus the BBC News box).
youtu.be
You can just about get away with the top BBC and bottom NEWS with that.
If they do what's been suggested by the poster above, it just looks silly and doesn't work. You don't need a graphic designer to tell you that.
However, this screams BBC One initial Chameleon refresh all over again with the new logo being slapped on old idents/titles because the new package isn't ready for whatever reason! It's just so amateur and I couldn't imagine ITV or any other 'main' broadcaster doing something so bodged!