[steve]

I don't dislike them as idents, but I do wonder whether the theme is strong enough. The film it's all hanging off is has passed me by, it doesn't feel like a big blockbuster centrepiece of the festive schedule in the way that the programmes/films associated with previous character Christmas idents have.

I think they work as standalone, personally. Given the abstract nature of some of the idents we get nowadays, they feel lovely and - more to the point - Christmassy by themselves. More I listen to them, more I really like the soundtrack to them. Beautifully composed - the night one especially.

[Josh]

Great idents but can't help but agree the white text on a white background does not work too well.

[Spencer]

https://twitter.com/bbcpress/status/1598603008803147776?s=46&t=Y-RUssjZxAeThhbq2zwL3A

I may be being thick, but I have no idea what that thing on the ground is supposed to be. Some kind of half-dead pheasant spitting Maltesers?

[Edit: I guess it must be the mole. Not sure why it’s brown.]

Moles aren’t brown?

They're black normally.

[all new phil]

Beautiful music. I like this a lot.

[JosiahStuart]

As an American, I have to say that these Christmas idents are beautiful. I like them just as much as the Shaun The Sheep idents from last year.

I understand why some of you are worried about not being able to see the word 'ONE' on the first ident. There's still enough of a shadow for you to see the word.

[TheGregmeister]

BBC One 2022 Christmas Idents | The Ident Review

Mod edit: Video link deleted

Rules: Please do not embed/link to social media-based video/stills content that has clearly been websnatched from a presentation website. The account is known to actively snatch others' content.

[JMT1985]

As an American, I have to say that these Christmas idents are beautiful. I like them just as much as the Shaun The Sheep idents from last year.

I understand why some of you are worried about not being able to see the word 'ONE' on the first ident. There's still enough of a shadow for you to see the word.

I believe in America, presentation like what we do here in Britain at Christmas time is not done there?

[Andrew Wood]

Snow effect from last year has returned

theident.gallery 

theident.gallery 

[IanJRedman]

Snowy BBC One blip in the junction before Strictly.

[dbl]

As an American, I have to say that these Christmas idents are beautiful. I like them just as much as the Shaun The Sheep idents from last year.

I understand why some of you are worried about not being able to see the word 'ONE' on the first ident. There's still enough of a shadow for you to see the word.

I believe in America, presentation like what we do here in Britain at Christmas time is not done there?

British television is a bit more elaborate when it comes to Christmas presentation. American broadcasters will change their OSP and promo looks for a more wintery/festive themed feel