Posts: 633
Threads: 16
Likes Received: 1,163 in 367 posts
Likes Given: 7,510
Joined: Jul 2022
What we've seen this year is just how much of the BBC's elections coverage these days relying on Huw Edwards himself and the energy that he brings to the long overnight shows - especially for the less exciting local elections which can be a slog. And Studio B looked amazing in election mode
As I said earlier, Laura was alright last night but she didn't have the gravitas that Huw brings to elections
(This post was last modified: 05-05-2023, 06:10 PM by
UTVLifer.)
Posts: 1,198
Threads: 0
Likes Received: 4,768 in 984 posts
Likes Given: 238
Joined: Aug 2022
(05-05-2023, 01:47 PM)Andrew Wrote: The daytime coverage has been pretty poor really, basically a 5 hour debate between the host and a revolving set of guests, with the actual bulk of the results being mostly sidelined.
Coburn was definitely the best of the presenters they had, but I absolutely agree that it was a very poor decision to have the afternoon - which is now when the main slurry of results occur - to be 'discussion' in a second-rate studio, with actual results as an afterthought. To be fair, I guess they signposted it as a Politics Live Special, but I didn't expect them to actually mean it.
My broader disdain for the panel debate-ification of news programming aside, why do they have such an issue with understanding that what people want from election coverage is results and analysis. A bit of political reaction fine, but I heard the HQ scripted soundbites the first 300 times the talking heads said them, there's no need for them to be taking priority over the steady stream of results coming in or the criminally underused analysis teams and BBC correspondents/regional political editors. To their credit, it looks like (fingers crossed) we've seen the back of Vine's abysmal VR segments, but there's still so many simple ways they can make a better election night programme - they have all the right resources, they just use them in completely the wrong order.
(This post was last modified: 05-05-2023, 09:40 PM by
DTV.)
Posts: 1,650
Threads: 8
Likes Received: 2,078 in 909 posts
Likes Given: 2,261
Joined: Jul 2022
Presentation wise, the overnight edition from B worked well, although I didn't gel to Laura in the same way I've done with Huw or David Dimbleby.
It all started to go a bit Pete Tong when the election programme resumed on BBC Two. When it was actually on, no issue but then suddenly we'd get the World feed of BBC News until the TOTH and then returned again.
Then we got hours of Politics Live, which I find dreadful because of the over reliance of guests instead of proper parliamentary coverage. I have no issue with Jo Coburn presenting, but it should have been a standard election format rather than padding with guests.
Posts: 1,000
Threads: 4
Likes Received: 2,032 in 631 posts
Likes Given: 17
Joined: Jul 2022
I agree about the extended Politics Live
You had a succession of Conservative MPs who all said the same thing, sat next to a succession of Labour MPs who said the same thing on their side, sat across from a left wing newspaper columnist or activist who all pretty much said the same thing, and then someone from a right wing organisation who also said the same thing - repeated hour after hour all day.
The main part of the results was banished to the newsroom with a badly angled screen with the actual results the smallest thing visible.
The following 12 users Like Andrew's post:12 users Like Andrew's post
• AJB39, Brekkie, chrisherald, DTV, Jeff, Kojak, LDN, London Lite, Omnipresent, Quantum+83, thePineapple, UTVLifer
Posts: 123
Threads: 0
Likes Received: 747 in 96 posts
Likes Given: 66
Joined: Jul 2022
(05-05-2023, 07:02 AM)UTVLifer Wrote: twitter.com
Oooh, is that a News Channel (UK opt) display of the Red Bee HUD (aka Presfax) I spot?
Posts: 270
Threads: 0
Likes Received: 564 in 171 posts
Likes Given: 331
Joined: Sep 2022
(06-05-2023, 09:56 AM)bbctvtechop Wrote: (05-05-2023, 07:02 AM)UTVLifer Wrote: twitter.com
Oooh, is that a News Channel (UK opt) display of the Red Bee HUD (aka Presfax) I spot?
That's the master (i.e. the base version the regions opt away from). UK is still coming from NBH at the moment.
Posts: 933
Threads: 0
Likes Received: 1,759 in 470 posts
Likes Given: 1,106
Joined: Jul 2022
Does the countdown originate from Red Bee or NBH?
Posts: 221
Threads: 0
Likes Received: 383 in 124 posts
Likes Given: 638
Joined: Sep 2022
(06-05-2023, 01:28 PM)harshy Wrote: Does the countdown originate from Red Bee or NBH?
Internationally it’s from Red Bee I think. They usually run the countdown till :00:00.
NBH runs it till :59:58 to make sure BBC One, Two and the international feed of the news channel has a clean opt-in.
Posts: 113
Threads: 0
Likes Received: 154 in 50 posts
Likes Given: 253
Joined: Oct 2022
Laura in the early hours was far better than Huw imho. She gelled with the guests and knew what area she was talking about.
Posts: 819
Threads: 5
Likes Received: 1,773 in 519 posts
Likes Given: 931
Joined: Aug 2022
(05-05-2023, 10:10 PM)Andrew Wrote: I agree about the extended Politics Live
You had a succession of Conservative MPs who all said the same thing, sat next to a succession of Labour MPs who said the same thing on their side, sat across from a left wing newspaper columnist or activist who all pretty much said the same thing, and then someone from a right wing organisation who also said the same thing - repeated hour after hour all day.
The main part of the results was banished to the newsroom with a badly angled screen with the actual results the smallest thing visible.
What gets me are the (ex?) GB News people whom the BBC constantly book. Anyone would think they didn't have their own channel to pontificate on!